The Ultimate Toilet Paper Showdown: Kirkland vs. Member's Mark

Choosing the Right Toilet Paper: Kirkland or Member's Mark?

Reading time : 1 minute, Discovery Chepe Id-666-VID
Published in 04-13-2025

Softness and Strength Test: Kirkland vs. Member's

When it comes to essential household products like toilet paper, many people wonder which brand offers the best quality, performance, and price. Two of the most popular brands at wholesale clubs are Kirkland Signature (from Costco) and Member's Mark (from Sam's Club). Both have built strong followings, but which one is truly better? Here is a comparison based on user experience and key features of each.

Kirkland Signature (Costco)

Pros:
Very soft and comfortable: Its texture is ideal for those who want a gentle feel during use.
Good roll longevity: Offers a high sheet count, making it last longer.
Doesn't fall apart easily: Prevents hassle during use or cleaning.
Sustainable manufacturing: FSC certified, meaning it comes from responsible sources.

Cons:
Too thick for some plumbing: Some users report clogs if their home has sensitive pipes.

Softness and Strength Test: Kirkland vs. Member's Mark Toilet Paper

Member's Mark (Sam's Club)

Pros:
Competitive price: Usually more affordable per unit than other brands.
Firm texture: While still soft, it has a slightly stronger feel that some users prefer.
High roll capacity: Rolls are large and ideal for large households.

Cons:
Less resistant under pressure: May tear if used too aggressively.
Can leave residue: Some users notice small fibers left behind after use.

Which one is better?

The choice between Kirkland and Member's Mark depends on your priorities:

If you prefer maximum softness, durability, and eco-friendly practices, then Kirkland might be the right choice.

If you're looking for affordability, larger rolls, and solid overall performance, then Member's Mark is a great option.

Both brands perform well, so the best way to decide is to try them both and see which suits your household needs better.

Have you tried both brands? Let us know which one you prefer and why.